2007 was a remarkable good year for records. So much so, that it’s hard to get my choices down to five — instead I’ve selected six, with two tying for first place. Sadly, Arcade Fire’s Neon Bible did not make the list. As much as I love their first LP, Funeral, Neon Bible suffered from what I call “Belle and Sebastian” syndrome, where each subsequent record is a shadow of the last. Neon Bible, despite a few good new songs (and one classic re-run from Us Kids Know), is not as good as Arcade Fire’s past efforts, and is not one of the best albums of the year.
That said, here’s my list for the best records of 2007:
5. The National, The Boxer
Moody, dark and beautiful, The National takes Joy Division, Bauhaus, Interpol, etc. and comes out with something surprisingly earnest and substantative. The Boxer is a fantastic album, from the opening chords of “Fake Empire” onward. Tina and I saw them open for Arcade Fire this year, and felt that they were better than the main band.
4. Menomena, Friend or Foe
Menomena patches together various snippets of a song using software that they created. The result is somewhat off-kilter, but surprisingly traditional. Favorite songs include “Wet and Rusting” and “Rotten Hell.” When they play live, they have to approximate the recorded songs with real instruments. Great stuff.
3. Shout Out Louds, Our Ill Wills
This Swedish band does their best Cure impression on this record, which wraps the whole thing in a sense of nostalgia. I know to some that’s not exactly a ringing endorsement, but Our Ill Wills surpasses simple pastiche into a sublime record of lost loves and wistful melancholy.
2. Of Montreal, Hissing Fauna, Are You the Destroyer?
This time around, Kevin Barnes dispenses with the Elephant Six-esque pop of the past in favor of a kind of manic blend of indie pop, electronic dance music, and pure madness. Personal in the same way that the best Mountain Goats records are personal, Barnes lays bear his own mental illness for us all to see. Sometimes uncomfortable, Hissing Fauna are You the Destroyer? is always brilliant.
1. Los Campesinos!, Sticking Fingers Into Sockets EP and International Tweexcore Underground Single
Imagine sprawling bands like Belle and Sebastian and Arcade Fire, but making pure indie pop in the vein of bands like Talulah Gosh and Bis. It’s been years since there’s been an indiepop band this good — they channel youthful energy and enthusiasim in a manner of great dead bands. The old record collectors would never admit that they’re the second coming, which is exactly what they are. Can’t wait for the full length.