Flags of our Fathers
Everything is about Iraq, even when it’s not.
Last night, I finally got around to watching FLAGS OF OUR FATHERS, which deals with the famous flag raising on Iwo Jima (both of them, actually), and the effects that moment had on the men who were there. Although Clint Eastwood isn’t exactly my idea of a great director, I have to say I came away impressed by what is in truth an anti-war film, one that lingers on the senseless cruelty of conflict and the losses — psychological and moral — suffered by war’s participants. It also deals quite significantly with the use of propaganda to engender public support, and provides one of the only unvarnished, unsentimental portrayals of World War II America you’ll ever see on film.
I haven’t even gotten to the racial subtext of the film, the constant indignities foisted upon Ira Hayes, the Native American “hero” who was tormented by Iwo Jima until his death by “exposure” a few years after the war. Some may remember Hayes as the subject of the Johnny Cash antiwar classic, “The Ballad of Ira Hayes,” and his experiences are emphasized heavily in the film.
This film is most certainly not the overly sentimental SAVING PRIVATE RYAN, which fictionalized and romanticized the war for a generation of Americans, myself included, who then went on to relive in a thousand times over in video games like MEDAL OF HONOR and CALL OF DUTY. RYAN’s main conceit is that the men of World War II were brave and noble heroes, ordinary men called to extraordinary acts by fate. They suffer, yes, but they were noble and good. FLAGS OF OUR FATHER takes a different tact — these were men traumatized by a brutal experience bigger than themselves. They sacrificed themselves for their friends, and did what they did on the battlefield to survive and help their friends live. And yet after that survival, they were tortured by guilt for having gotten off that mountain of rock in the Pacific, when deep down they felt they should have died there, too.
Although Eastwood quite accurately depicts the deep racial hatred that drove combat on Iwo Jima, both on the American and Japanese side, unlike Spielberg’s RYAN, the Japanese are more than just stock villains. As the camera lingers on their dead young faces, the dead Japanese soldiers, so fanatical and brutal moments before, also seem tragically human. They are also victims of the war.
I can’t wait to see the companion piece, Eastwood’s LETTERS FROM IWO JIMA, which tells the story of the same battle from the Japanese perspective. I have no doubt that it will tell the same story.