Well, I finally got around to stopping by Big Monkey comics, yesterday, to pick up the trade of Marvel’s CIVIL WAR mini series. I haven’t read a super hero comic in a long, long time — in fact, it’s been awhile since I’ve read a comic, period. Being back in a comic shop was a bit strange — I gave up my regular comics habit when my girls were born two years ago. Despite having read comics for over 20 years, I can’t help but feel like an outsider.
Comics shops are weird places. Cool, but weird. There’s a culture there, a community that senses whether or not you’re a member. I felt like just another ex-comics fan who had come to the shop to belatedly check out that big “event” everyone was talking about six months ago. In many ways, I felt embarassed.
But I bought the book, anyway.
Flash back: I first began my obsession with comics when I was 11 years old back in 1986. My parents had taken me camping with my grandmother on Chincoteague Island in Virginia, and I was bored. There was a little mom and pop store on the island filled with comics — and my grandmother kindly bought several for me. These included Uncanny X-Men, Iron Man and West Coast Avengers. I remember reading them on a picnic bench, surrounded by trees and buzzing flies. I read them again and again. When I got back home, I had to seek more out — and thus began a nearly lifelong fandom.
Of all the books I read, Iron Man was my favorite. This was the David Micheline/Mark Bright era, and I was blown away by the high-tech coolness of the character. Tony Stark took on illegal arms dealers, evil corporations and his own alcoholism. I liked that he was a flawed guy, that he wasn’t perfect. And I especially liked that he could blow things up spectacularly with his powered armor.
It’s from this angle that I approached CIVIL WAR, which I found to be a shallow exploitation of characters I’d cherished as a kid. Mark Millar, who so spectacularly re-invented the super hero comic with his run on the Authority clearly has no respect for these characters. This was clear when he was working on ULTIMATE X-MEN and THE ULTIMATES, where he repeatedly humiliated them. However, since these were alternate takes on classic characters, Millar had the freedom to do what he wanted — you could accept Captain America as a right-wing fascist, since he wasn’t the real Captain America, anyway. But CIVIL WAR takes place in the real Marvel Universe (TM), with fifty years of continuity. What happens there, for all intents and purposes, happens for real.
In a nutshell, the story centers around an incident where the town of Stamford, Connecticut is destroyed as the result of a group of reality-show superheroes taking on villains far outside their league. In response, the country demands the government do something about reigning in super heroes — licensing them, making them both “official” and “accountable.” Captain America disagrees with this, and takes a wide assortment of characters “underground.” Tony Stark agrees with it, and takes a wider assortment of characters on a hunting expedition to apprehend the “rogue heroes.” Eventually a minor hero gets killed and things escalate from there.
In many ways CIVIL WAR is an allegory for George W. Bush’s America and the post-9/11 era, but to achieve that allegory it takes classic beloved characters like Iron Man and Reed Richards and turns them into complete wankers, and others like the X-Men and Spiderman, and makes them out to be pathetic losers. In many ways it reads like bad fan-fiction — there’s a sense that Millar doesn’t care about the history of these characters, and everything that happens is to fuel the books sensational themes of “hero vs. hero,” and not to service the story, itself. Thus, Spiderman agrees to give his identity away on television, Reed Richards develops a superhuman prison in the Negative Zone, and Tony Stark decides to become a complete fascist. And the fact that Stark’s victory over Captain America is depicted as a happy ending, makes me wonder if I live on the same planet as Mark Millar. How authoritarianism can be depicted as a victory is beyond my comprehension.
Look, I understand that franchises can only go on too long before they repeat themselves so many times that their original greatness is lost — STAR TREK is a case in point, as is both the MARVEL and DC comic book universes. I gave up on super hero comics largely because of how sick I was of them and their conventions. But re-inventing them shouldn’t involve disrespecting what’s come before — and it certainly shouldn’t be this ugly.